0
Article Sign in to save

Using systems mapping to understand the constraints and enablers of solutions to plastic pollution

Aquaculture Reports 2024 9 citations

AI summary Read the abstract

A one-day group model building workshop with 25 plastic pollution researchers generated a causal loop diagram identifying 18 factors and 7 feedback loops governing constraints and enablers of solutions to plastic pollution. Key leverage factors included effective legislation, funding, public education, behavior change, innovation, and waste management, with findings emphasizing that no single 'silver bullet' solution exists and a holistic systems approach is necessary.

Plastic pollution is now considered globally ubiquitous, irreversible, and a planetary boundary threat. Solutions are urgently needed but their development and application are hampered by the complexity and scale of the issue. System dynamics is a technique used to understand complex behaviours of systems through model building and is useful for conceptualising the relationships between various interacting, dynamic factors, and identifying potential intervention points within the system where specific policies or innovations might have the greatest impact or meet with the greatest resistance. Here, twenty-five participants (all scientific researchers of various career stages, disciplines and nationalities working on plastic pollution) completed a series of exercises through an interactive, iterative group model building exercise during a one-day workshop. The process culminated in the generation of a causal loop diagram, based on participants' perspectives, illustrating the dynamic factors relating to the constraints and enablers of solutions to plastic pollution. A total of 18 factors and seven feedback loops were identified. Key factors influencing the system were Effective legislation, Funding, Public education and awareness, Behaviour change, Innovation, and Effective waste management. Our findings highlight that there is no single driver, or 'silver bullet', for resolving this complex issue and that a holistic approach should be adopted to create effective and systemic change.

More Papers Like This

Article

System-wide assessment of plastic pollution in Indonesia: external stakeholder mapping

AI summary Read the abstract

This study used the Complex Value Optimisation for Resource Recovery (CVORR) systems-based method to identify and map 111 external stakeholders across 11 groups in the plastics value chain in Banyuwangi, Indonesia. The analysis revealed significant power dynamics and lock-ins where downstream waste management emphasis overshadows upstream prevention, highlighting the need for cross-stakeholder collaboration to achieve systemic change in plastics management.

Article Tier 2

Solutions to Plastic Pollution: A Conceptual Framework to Tackle a Wicked Problem

AI summary Read the abstract

This review proposed a conceptual framework for organizing the diverse technological, governance, and societal solutions to global plastic pollution, mapping the value-laden issues that drive different actors' preferences for particular approaches.

Article

Taming plastic pollution—a systematic mapping of the literature on plastic policies between 2009 and 2024

AI summary Read the abstract

This systematic review mapped 15 years of academic literature on plastic pollution policy and politics, finding that research has focused heavily on policy inventories, impact assessments, and global governance architecture, while systematic evaluations of policy effectiveness and actor-level political analyses remain scarce. The authors argue that future research must shift toward understanding the politics of compliance and country-level performance to inform the effectiveness of an emerging multilateral plastics agreement.

Article

Barriers to recycling plastics from the perspectives of industry stakeholders: a qualitative study

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers conducted a qualitative study with industry stakeholders across the plastic value chain, identifying systemic barriers to plastic recycling — including economic disincentives, infrastructure gaps, and design-for-disposal norms — that consumer-focused research has largely overlooked.

Article

Will innovation solve the global plastic contamination: how much innovation is needed for that?

AI summary Read the abstract

This study developed an ecological-economic world model to simulate how much innovation is needed to achieve a significant reduction in marine plastic accumulation, finding that no single type of solution is sufficient. Only combined upstream and downstream interventions—from source reduction to mid-chain management and ocean cleanup—could reduce ocean plastic stocks to 50% of 2010 levels, with 11.89% annual ocean removal required to achieve that ambitious target.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper