0
Article Sign in to save

Terrestrial ecotoxicity of plastics: Effect factors for life cycle impact assessment - Data retrieved from ecotoxicity experiments and Python code for analyses and effect factor calculation

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers compiled 680 ecotoxicity data points from soil experiments with plastics to develop species sensitivity distribution curves and calculate terrestrial ecotoxicity effect factors for life cycle impact assessment, accounting for polymer type, size, shape, and soil conditions. This dataset and methodology directly advance microplastic pollution research by providing standardized quantitative tools for assessing the terrestrial ecological risks of plastic emissions across different polymer types and environmental scenarios.

Study Type Environmental

This repository contains (i) the data extracted from ecotoxicity experiments with plastics in soil, which were used to analyze the factors influencing effect concentrations, develop species sensitivity distribution curves, and calculate exposure-and-effect factors for terrestrial ecotoxicity of plastic pollution (SM2), and (ii) the code used for the statistical analysis (SM3) and calculation of terrestrial ecotoxicity exposure-and-effect factors for inclusion in life cycle assessment (SM4). The methodology for the data collection and conversion is described in the article linked below. Briefly, we identified relevant scientific literature by using the search term and exclusion criteria indicated in the article and extracted 680 data points: one per emission type (polymer type, size class, and shape) and target organism, as listed in the Excel file "SM2_Effect-oncentrations.xlsx". For each data point, we recorded details regarding (i) emission characteristics: polymer type and chemical family, size, and shape, (ii) experimental conditions: soil used and water holding capacity, (iii) target organism characteristics: kingdom and species, and (iv) measurement (meta) data: dose descriptor, endpoint, and effect concentration in g/kg soil. We applied the uncertainty factors for exposure time (UFtime) and dose descriptor (UFdose) of Wigger et al. (2020) to systematically address uncertainty arising from heterogeneous ecotoxicity data. For HONEC values, we defined three treatment options: 1. exclusion of HONEC values (‘noH’), 2. application of the same UFdose as for NOEC values based on the precautionary principle and basing UFdose for NOEC values on Aurisano et al. (2019) (‘H1’), and 3. application of the same UFdose as for NOEC values based on the precautionary principle and assigning a conversion factor of 0.5 to NOEC values (‘H2’) in line with ECHA (2008). All data points were classified as acute or chronic based on species-dependent thresholds (Tunali et al. 2023). For acute values, three treatment options were defined: 1. exclusion of acute values (‘noac’), 2. application of a UFtime of 10 (‘UFt10’) based on Brix et al. (2001) and Wigger et al. (2020), and 3. application of a UFtime of 2 (‘UFt2’) based on Rosenbaum et al. (2008), Fantke et al. (2017), and Lavoie et al. (2021). Each scenario represents a unique combination of a HONEC treatment and an acute-data treatment, resulting in nine scenarios in total: noH-noac, noH-UFt10, noH-UFt2, H1-noac, H1-UFt10, H1-UFt2, H2-noac, H2-UFt10, and H2-UFt2. Scenario names indicate the treatment of HONEC values (noH, H1, or H2) followed by the treatment of acute values (noac, UFt10, or UFt2). References: Aurisano, Nicolò; Albizzati, Paola Federica; Hauschild, Michael; Fantke, Peter (2019): Extrapolation Factors for Characterizing Freshwater Ecotoxicity Effects. In Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 38 (11), pp. 2568–2582. DOI: 10.1002/etc.4564. Brix, K. V.; DeForest, D. K.; Adams, W. J. (2001): Assessing acute and chronic copper risks to freshwater aquatic life using species sensitivity distributions for different taxonomic groups. In Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 20 (8), pp. 1846–1856. ECHA (2008): Guidance on information requirements and chemical safety assessment. Chapter R.10: Characterisation of dose [concentration]‐response for environment. Edited by European Chemicals Agency. Helsinki (FI). Fantke, Peter; Bijster, Marian; Guignard, Cécile; Hauschild, Michael; Huijbregts, Mark; Jolliet, Olivier et al. (2017): USEtox® 2.0 Documentation (Version 1.1). Lavoie, Jérôme; Boulay, Anne‐Marie; Bulle, Cécile (2021): Aquatic micro‐ and nano‐plastics in life cycle assessment: Development of an effect factor for the quantification of their physical impact on biota. In J Ind Ecol. DOI: 10.1111/jiec.13140. Rosenbaum, Ralph K.; Bachmann, Till M.; Gold, Lois Swirsky; Huijbregts, Mark A. J.; Jolliet, Olivier; Juraske, Ronnie et al. (2008): USEtox—the UNEP-SETAC toxicity model. Recommended characterisation factors for human toxicity and freshwater ecotoxicity in life cycle impact assessment. In Int J Life Cycle Assess 13 (7), pp. 532–546. DOI: 10.1007/s11367-008-0038-4. Tunali, Merve; Adam, Véronique; Nowack, Bernd (2023): Probabilistic environmental risk assessment of microplastics in soils. In Geoderma 430, p. 116315. DOI: 10.1016/j.geoderma.2022.116315. Wigger, Henning; Kawecki, Delphine; Nowack, Bernd; Adam, Véronique (2020): Systematic Consideration of Parameter Uncertainty and Variability in Probabilistic Species Sensitivity Distributions. In Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management 16 (2), pp. 211–222. DOI: 10.1002/ieam.4214.

More Papers Like This

Article

Terrestrial ecotoxicity of plastics: Effect factors for life cycle impact assessment - Data retrieved from ecotoxicity experiments and Python code for analyses and effect factor calculation

AI summary Read the abstract

This data repository presents 680 ecotoxicity data points from soil plastic experiments along with Python code for statistical analysis and calculation of terrestrial ecotoxicity exposure-and-effect factors for life cycle impact assessment, covering multiple polymer types, size classes, and shapes. The standardized effect factors for soil plastic pollution enable more accurate comparative risk assessments of microplastic contamination in terrestrial ecosystems, a critical gap in environmental impact modeling.

Article Tier 2

Soil-dwelling species-based biomarker as a sensitivity-risk measure of terrestrial ecosystems response to microplastics: A dose–response modeling approach

AI summary Read the abstract

A dose-response modeling approach was applied to data from soil-dwelling organisms to assess the relative sensitivity of terrestrial ecosystems to microplastic contamination, producing species sensitivity distributions as a risk metric. The analysis revealed that certain soil invertebrates are particularly vulnerable even at relatively low microplastic concentrations.

Article Tier 2

Terrestrial Ecotoxicity of Plastics: Effect Factors for Life Cycle Impact Assessment.

AI summary Read the abstract

Scientists analyzed hundreds of studies to figure out how harmful plastic buildup in soil is to plants and small creatures like worms, creating a new scoring system to measure this damage. They found that plastics, especially tiny nanoplastics, are much less toxic to soil life than to water-based ecosystems, meaning we can't just assume plastic pollution affects land and water the same way. This matters because it gives researchers better tools to accurately assess how our growing plastic waste problem impacts farmland and the food chain, since soil is becoming a major dumping ground for plastic debris.

Article

Microplastics in Terrestrial Ecosystems: Detection, Transport Pathways, and Ecotoxicological Risks

AI summary Read the abstract

This comprehensive review synthesizes current knowledge on microplastic detection, transport pathways, and ecotoxicological effects in terrestrial ecosystems, identifying critical gaps in sampling methodology and risk assessment frameworks. It establishes that microplastics pose measurable threats to soil biota, plants, and microbial communities, while calling for standardized protocols to improve data comparability across studies.

Article Tier 2

Bayesian species sensitivity distribution modeling for microplastic particles: integrating particle characteristics and intra-species variation

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers applied hierarchical Bayesian modeling to develop species sensitivity distributions for microplastics, incorporating particle size, shape, and censored effect data across up to 33 species, finding that smaller particles and fiber shapes are associated with lower chronic no-effect concentrations and estimating hazardous concentrations spanning several orders of magnitude.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper