We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
An alternative approach to risk rank chemicals on the threat they pose to the aquatic environment
Summary
This paper proposed an alternative approach for ranking chemicals by the threat they pose to aquatic ecosystems, integrating exposure and hazard data in a more ecologically meaningful way than standard risk quotient methods.
This work presents a new and unbiased method of risk ranking chemicals based on the threat they pose to the aquatic environment. The study ranked 12 metals, 23 pesticides, 11 other persistent organic pollutants (POPs), 13 pharmaceuticals, 10 surfactants and similar compounds and 2 nanoparticles (total of 71) of concern against one another by comparing their median UK river water and median ecotoxicity effect concentrations. To complement this, by giving an assessment on potential wildlife impacts, risk ranking was also carried out by comparing the lowest 10th percentile of the effects data with the highest 90th percentile of the exposure data. In other words, risk was pared down to just toxicity versus exposure. Further modifications included incorporating bioconcentration factors, using only recent water measurements and excluding either lethal or sub-lethal effects. The top ten chemicals, based on the medians, which emerged as having the highest risk to organisms in UK surface waters using all the ecotoxicity data were copper, aluminium, zinc, ethinylestradiol (EE2), linear alkylbenzene sulfonate (LAS), triclosan, manganese, iron, methomyl and chlorpyrifos. By way of contrast, using current UK environmental quality standards as the comparator to median UK river water concentrations would have selected 6 different chemicals in the top ten. This approach revealed big differences in relative risk; for example, zinc presented a million times greater risk then metoprolol and LAS 550 times greater risk than nanosilver. With the exception of EE2, most pharmaceuticals were ranked as having a relatively low risk.
Sign in to start a discussion.
More Papers Like This
A New Method for Environmental Risk Assessment of Pollutants Based on Multi-dimensional Risk Factors
Researchers proposed a new synthetic risk factor (SRF) method for environmental risk assessment that integrates toxicity endpoint values, environmental exposure levels, persistence properties, and compartment-specific features across multiple environmental media into a single multi-dimensional evaluation framework. The approach addresses a key limitation of traditional chemical risk assessment methods that assess toxicity and exposure without accounting for persistent pollutant behavior across different environmental compartments.
Exposures in Aquatic Ecosystems: The Weak Link in Risk Assessments - A Critical Perspective
This critical perspective argues that exposure assessment is the weakest link in aquatic risk assessments, because the concentrations organisms actually experience in the environment are often poorly measured or estimated. Improving exposure assessment is directly relevant to better evaluating the actual risks posed by microplastics in aquatic systems.
Characterizing Freshwater Ecotoxicity of More Than 9000 Chemicals by Combining Different Levels of Available Measured Test Data with In Silico Predictions
Researchers developed a method combining laboratory toxicity data with computer predictions to estimate the ecological hazards of over 9,000 chemicals in freshwater environments. They found that using even limited experimental data alongside predictive models significantly improved the accuracy of environmental risk assessments. The approach could help regulators better evaluate the ecological impact of the thousands of chemicals, including plastic-related compounds, that currently lack comprehensive toxicity data.
Predicted aquatic exposure effects from a national urban stormwater study
Researchers estimated cumulative acute risks to aquatic ecosystems from contaminant mixtures in episodic stormwater discharges across the US, revealing significant potential exposure effects on multiple trophic levels.
Advances in aquatic toxicology for predicting effects of multiple pollutants on aquatic organisms
This review examines advances in aquatic toxicology for predicting how mixtures of contaminants — heavy metals, pesticides, pharmaceuticals, and microplastics — interact in aquatic organisms, highlighting computational modeling and mixture toxicity approaches as key tools for environmental risk assessment.