0
Article Tier 2 Environmental Sources Sign in to save

Response to the reviewer comments #2

2020

AI summary Read the abstract

This is a second reviewer response document for the same study on microplastic and microglass effects on soil microbial communities. The reviewer raises concerns about the experimental design and suggests caution in interpreting the results. This is a peer review commentary rather than an original research article.

This manuscript investigates the effects of microplastic and microglass particles on the structure of microbial communities in soil using soil microcosms that have been spiked with these contaminants. The issue of micro-particles in the environment is very topical, and while there is a lot of information about the impact of macro-plastics C1

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Response to the reviewer comments #1

AI summary Read the abstract

This is a reviewer response document for a study on the effects of microplastic and microglass particles on soil microbial communities. The reviewer positively evaluates the manuscript and provides constructive feedback. This is a peer review response rather than an original research article.

Article Tier 2

Peer Review #1 of "Effects of biodegradable plastic film mulching on soil microbial communities in two agroecosystems (v0.2)"

AI summary Read the abstract

This is a peer review for a study comparing the effects of biodegradable plastic mulch films versus polyethylene mulch on soil microbial communities. The reviewer provides feedback on experimental design and interpretation of results for this agriculturally relevant microplastic question.

Article Tier 2

Reply on RC2

AI summary Read the abstract

This is an author response to a second reviewer comment on a study examining microplastic effects on soil properties and water erosion. The response engages with methodological critiques and the significance of findings for agricultural and erosion research.

Article Tier 2

Review

AI summary Read the abstract

This manuscript investigated how microplastic and microglass particles affect microbial community structure in soil microcosms, finding that plastic contamination alters terrestrial microbial communities in ways that have been far less studied than impacts on marine wildlife.

Article Tier 2

Peer Review #2 of "Effects of plastic mulching on the accumulation and distribution of macro and micro plastics in soils of two farming systems in Northwest China (v0.1)"

AI summary Read the abstract

This is an earlier-round peer review document for the same study on plastic mulch accumulation in Chinese agricultural soils. The reviewer evaluates methodology and provides feedback on the original version of the manuscript. This is a peer review commentary rather than an original research article.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper