We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Quality assessment of research studies on microplastics in soils: A methodological perspective
AI summary Read the abstract
A methodological quality assessment of published soil microplastic studies identified widespread inconsistencies in extraction, identification, and reporting protocols that limit comparability and reliability of findings. The review recommends adoption of standardized quality criteria to improve the rigor and reproducibility of soil microplastic research.
Microplastics have become a global concern, and soil acts as a major sink for plastic pollution. Due to rapid development of soil microplastics research, various analysis methods have been developed, but require proper consistency and standard procedures. The objective of this study was to appraise a quality assessment concerning soil microplastics from a methodological perspective. Nine studies were selected for the quality assessment exercise based on methodological investigations on soil microplastics and were evaluated based on the adapted Criteria for Reporting and Evaluating Ecotoxicity Data (CRED) method. The highest score obtained by an individual study was 21 while the lowest was 14, leaving a wide score gap which indicated inconsistency amongst the studies. Criterion with the highest average score of 2.0 was obtained for sample size and data reporting. The lowest average score of 0.89 was for the negative control. In conclusion, the total average scores for all eleven criteria were 1.56. Current quality assessment perceived that there was room for improvement and betterment of quality assurance for studies on microplastics and a form of guideline on methodological aspects of soil microplastics studies. It was suggested that future microplastics studies should methodically include quality assurance/quality control (QA/QC) protocols in every process to ensure that good quality data is produced and applied in the risk assessment process.
More Papers Like This
A methodological approach of the current literature on microplastic contamination in terrestrial environments: Current knowledge and baseline considerations
AI summary Read the abstract
This review of microplastic pollution in terrestrial and agricultural soils finds that a lack of standardized extraction and identification procedures makes most studies incomparable, calling for baseline contamination controls and harmonized reporting of concentrations, morphotypes, and analytical methods. The authors identify knowledge gaps for future research and provide minimum recommended procedures for field studies.
Sample Collection, Preparation, and Identification of Microplastics in Soil: Issues and Recommendations
AI summary Read the abstract
An evaluation of microplastic sampling and identification protocols from 39 global soil studies found major inconsistencies in sample collection strategies, preparation methods, and detection techniques, and proposed standardized recommendations to improve data comparability.
Microplastic in Soil: a Review of Detection Methods
AI summary Read the abstract
This review examines published approaches for detecting and identifying microplastics in soil environments, synthesizing sampling, extraction, and characterization methods to address the lack of standardization that hinders cross-study comparisons. Researchers found that unifying detection methods is essential for developing a common understanding of microplastic prevalence and impact in terrestrial ecosystems.
Status quo of operation procedures for soil sampling to analyze microplastics
AI summary Read the abstract
Researchers reviewed 106 studies on measuring microplastics in soil and found widespread inconsistency in sampling methods, sample sizes, and reporting standards, making it nearly impossible to compare results across studies. They call for a standardized protocol to ensure reproducible, comparable data that can actually inform policy to limit microplastic contamination of agricultural and natural soils.
Towards regulatory measures for microplastics in soils: further challenges and QA/QC guidelines for harmonized workflows
AI summary Read the abstract
Researchers critically examined existing regulations and methodological practices for measuring plastic pollution in soils, identifying the absence of harmonized workflows as a key barrier to actionable risk assessment, and proposed a quality assurance and quality control framework to improve data comparability and support effective soil protection policy.
Research digests by email
When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.