0
Article Tier 2 Environmental Sources Human Health Effects Marine & Wildlife Policy & Risk Sign in to save

Microplastic Effect Tests Should Use a Standard Heterogeneous Mixture: Multifarious Impacts among 16 Benthic Invertebrate Species Detected under Ecologically Relevant Test Conditions

Environmental Science & Technology 2023 20 citations

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers tested how environmentally realistic microplastic mixtures affect 16 species of bottom-dwelling invertebrates. Some species showed negative effects like reduced growth and reproduction at microplastic concentrations already found in nature, while others were unaffected even at high doses. The study argues that standardized, real-world plastic mixtures should replace simple lab-grade particles in future testing to get more reliable risk assessments.

Body Systems
Study Type Environmental

Microplastics require a risk assessment framework that takes their multidimensionality into account while exclusively considering robust data. Therefore, effect tests should use a diverse, environmentally relevant microplastic (ERMP) standard material that adheres to high-quality requirements. In this study, we provide chronic dose-effect relationships and effect thresholds for 16 benthic species exposed to ERMP. The ERMP was created from plastic items collected from natural sources and cryogenically milled to represent the diversity of microplastics. The test design met 20 previously published quality assurance and quality control criteria. Adverse effect thresholds (EC10) were determined at ERMP concentrations of 0.11 ± 0.17% sediment dry weight (Gammarus pulex, growth), 0.49 ± 0.68% sediment dry weight (Lumbriculus variegatus, growth), and 1.90 ± 1.08% sediment dry weight (L. variegatus, reproduction). A positive effect of microplastics, such as decreased mortality, was observed for Cerastoderma edule (EC10 = 0.021 ± 0.027% sediment dry weight) and Sphaerium corneum (EC10 = 7.67 ± 3.41% sediment dry weight), respectively. Several of these laboratory-based single-species effect thresholds for ERMP occurred at concentrations lower than those found in the environment. For other species, no significant effects were detected up to an ERMP dose of 10% dry weight.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Microplastic exposure studies should be environmentally realistic

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers argue that many laboratory studies on microplastic effects use concentrations far higher than what is actually found in the environment, which can lead to misleading conclusions about real-world risks. They call for experiments that better reflect environmental conditions, including realistic particle sizes, shapes, and concentrations. The study emphasizes that more environmentally relevant research is needed to accurately assess the true ecological threat of microplastic pollution.

Article Tier 2

Microplastics and nanoplastics toxicity assays: A revision towards to environmental-relevance in water environment

AI summary Read the abstract

This review evaluates how well current laboratory toxicity tests for micro and nanoplastics reflect real-world conditions in water environments. The authors found that most studies use pristine plastic particles at concentrations far higher than what is found in nature, limiting the relevance of their findings. The paper calls for more environmentally realistic testing approaches to better understand the actual risks of plastic particle pollution.

Article Tier 2

Microplastics versus natural mineral particles. How to create and test them while maintaining environmental relevance

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers developed standardized methods for creating environmentally relevant microplastic and mineral particle mixtures to test whether microplastics cause different effects than natural particles. They exposed freshwater worms to both types of particles over 28 days and found that microplastics reduced reproduction, but only under low organic matter conditions. The study suggests that the biological effects of microplastics depend heavily on the surrounding environmental context.

Article Tier 2

Relevant and Realistic Assessments of Micro- and Nanoplastics in the Environment

AI summary Read the abstract

This paper discusses methodological challenges in microplastic risk assessment, arguing that studies using only clean, uniform lab-prepared particles may not reflect the complex, mixed-type plastic particles actually found in the environment. More realistic experimental conditions are needed to generate data that accurately predicts ecological harm from microplastic pollution.

Article Tier 2

Comprehending the complexity of microplastic organismal exposures and effects, to improve testing frameworks

AI summary Read the abstract

This review argues that standard toxicity testing frameworks are poorly suited to capture the complexity of microplastic exposures in real environments, proposing improved testing approaches that account for particle mixtures, realistic concentrations, and species-specific feeding behaviors.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper