0
Article Tier 2 Environmental Sources Sign in to save

Evidence of deviations between experimental and empirical mixing lengths: Multi-discharge field tests in an arid river system

Water Research 2024 2 citations

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers conducted field tests of wastewater mixing zones in an arid river system to compare actual contaminant mixing lengths with those predicted by standard empirical equations. The study found significant deviations between predicted and observed mixing, suggesting that current regulatory approaches may underestimate the distance required for contaminants like microplastics and pharmaceuticals to fully dilute downstream of treatment plant discharges.

Study Type Environmental

Despite advances in wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) efficiencies, multiple contaminants of concern, such as microplastics, pharmaceuticals, and per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) remain largely untreated near discharge points and can be highly concentrated before they are fully mixed within the receiving river. Environmental agencies enforce mixing zone permits for the temporary exceedance of water quality parameters beyond targeted control levels under the assumption that contaminants are well-mixed and diluted downstream of mixing lengths, which are typically quantified using empirical equations derived from one-dimensional transport models. Most of these equations were developed in the 1970s and have been assumed to be standard practice since then. However, their development and validation lacked the technological advances required to test them in the field and under changing flow conditions. While new monitoring techniques such as remote sensing and infrared imaging have been employed to visualize mixing lengths and test the validity of empirical equations, those methods cannot be easily repeated due to high costs or flight restrictions. We investigated the application of Lagrangian and Eulerian monitoring approaches to experimentally quantify mixing lengths downstream of a WWTP discharging into the Rio Grande near Albuquerque, New Mexico (USA). Our data spans river to WWTP discharges ranging between 2-22x, thus providing a unique dataset to test long-standing empirical equations in the field. Our results consistently show empirical equations could not describe our experimental mixing lengths. Specifically, while our experimental data revealed "bell-shaped" mixing lengths as a function of increasing river discharges, all empirical equations predicted monotonically increasing mixing lengths. Those mismatches between experimental and empirical mixing lengths are likely due to the existence of threshold processes defining mixing at different flow regimes, i.e., jet diffusion at low flows, the Coanda effect at intermediate flows, and turbulent mixing at higher flows, which are unaccounted for by the one-dimensional empirical formulas. Our results call for a review of the use of empirical mixing lengths in streams and rivers to avoid widespread exposures to emerging contaminants.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Wastewater Discharge Transports Riverine Microplastics over Long Distances

AI summary Read the abstract

This study demonstrated that wastewater discharge transports riverine microplastics over long distances downstream, with treatment plant effluent contributing significantly to the total microplastic load in receiving rivers.

Article Tier 2

The role of biofilm and hydrodynamics on the fate of microplastic particles in rivers: an experimental study

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers conducted experimental flume studies to investigate how biofilm formation and hydrodynamic conditions jointly govern microplastic particle fate in rivers, examining why some urbanized and industrialized river reaches show no significant upstream-to-downstream increase in microplastic concentration despite theoretical inputs.

Article Tier 2

Modelling microplastic and solute dispersion in fluvial environments

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers experimentally investigated the transport of microplastics through fluvial environments with submerged vegetation canopies, comparing dispersion and mixing of neutrally buoyant polyethylene microplastics and dissolved solutes across varying flow conditions. Longitudinal dispersion coefficients for microplastics and solutes were strongly correlated within vegetated flows regardless of canopy height or flow complexity, and a hydrodynamic model robustly predicted microplastic mixing. The findings show that existing solute transport models can be adapted to quantify microplastic fate in vegetated river systems.

Article Tier 2

Riverine Microplastic Pollution in the Pearl River Delta, China: Are Modeled Estimates Accurate?

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers compared field measurements of microplastic loads in Pearl River Delta tributaries with model-based estimates, finding significant discrepancies that suggest current models either underestimate or overestimate emissions depending on assumptions used. Improving model accuracy requires better local emission data and validation against diverse river systems.

Article Tier 2

Methods for measuring and modelling plastic transport and accumulation in large rivers

AI summary Read the abstract

This study reviews and evaluates methods for measuring and modeling plastic transport and accumulation in large rivers, finding that sampling strategies, flow variability, and particle heterogeneity make quantification challenging. Researchers propose a standardized measurement framework to improve comparability across river systems and enable global flux estimates.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper