0
Article ? AI-assigned paper type based on the abstract. Classification may not be perfect — flag errors using the feedback button. Tier 2 ? Original research — experimental, observational, or case-control study. Direct primary evidence. Environmental Sources Marine & Wildlife Policy & Risk Sign in to save

Comments and discussion concerning ‘Sorption behavior of tebuconazole on microplastics: kinetics, isotherms and influencing factors’ [Environ Technol. 2023;44:3937–3948]

Environmental Technology 2025
Jean‐Claude Bollinger, François Bordas, Eva Martínková, Jana Jaklová Dytrtová, Michael Komárek

Summary

Researchers reanalyzed data from a published study on tebuconazole pesticide sorption onto polystyrene, polypropylene, and polyamide-6 microplastics, identifying critical flaws in the original kinetics and isotherm methodology and the interpretation of metal cation effects on sorption behavior.

The widespread use of synthetic polymers since the mid-twentieth century has led to significant environmental pollution from microplastics (MPs). These MPs, which persist in ecosystems, can interact with various pollutants, including pesticides such as tebuconazole (TEB). The subject paper investigates the sorption behaviour of TEB on different types of MPs (polystyrene, polypropylene, and polyamide-6), focusing on the kinetics and isotherms of these interactions. The role of metal cations (Al, Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn) in influencing TEB sorption is also investigated. Our findings highlight critical flaws that invalidate the original article, mainly in the interpretation of TEB physicochemical properties, such as pKa and speciation, and the importance of considering metal ion complexation in environmental risk assessment. The sorption models used by the original authors, although widely used, are questioned for their accuracy in representing real-world scenarios.

Share this paper