0
Article Sign in to save

Unlocking the biobased future: investigating recycling lock-ins and corporate power in the adoption of biobased food packaging

Bulletin of Science and Practice 2025 3 citations

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers investigated how incumbent corporate power and recycling lock-in — where existing plastic infrastructure resists adoption of new polymers — hinder the transition to biobased food packaging, concluding that dominant players both block and selectively enable biobased adoption depending on competitive advantage.

Polymers
Body Systems

Abstract Adverse impacts of plastic can be reduced by shifting to a circular bioeconomy with biobased plastics. Incumbents face barriers, including the alleged “recycling lock-in”, hindering the adoption of new polymers due to the current plastic packaging system. Corporate power is crucial in promoting this shift. This study focuses on corporate power in the Dutch plastic packaging sector, analyzing conflicts of interest and barriers in transitioning to a circular bioeconomy. Market-based Instruments’ effectiveness in promoting circularity among food companies is explored. Fifteen incumbents in Dutch plastic food packaging sector were interviewed. Reasons for not widely using biobased polymers are: technical performance issues, higher prices, limited availability and lack of recycling infrastructure. Moreover, existing recycling infrastructure, regulations, and practices are optimized for fossil-based polymers, creating lock-ins for the inclusion of new materials. Despite no legal barriers, companies are hesitant to use biobased plastics due to system challenges. They struggle to transition from fossil-based to biobased plastic packaging due to resistance to change. Power dynamics analysis shows that the petrochemical industry, Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) sector, and retail dominance has decreased in the past decade, with governmental measures increasing the influence of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and recyclers. No single entity controls the system.

More Papers Like This

Article

Barriers to recycling plastics from the perspectives of industry stakeholders: a qualitative study

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers conducted a qualitative study with industry stakeholders across the plastic value chain, identifying systemic barriers to plastic recycling — including economic disincentives, infrastructure gaps, and design-for-disposal norms — that consumer-focused research has largely overlooked.

Article

Competing narratives inhibit a circular economy for bio‐based plastic packaging: Insights from a social innovation lab study in Brazil, Canada, Poland and the UK

AI summary Read the abstract

A social innovation lab study across Brazil, Canada, Poland, and the UK found that competing narratives and lack of end-of-life infrastructure are the primary barriers preventing bio-based compostable plastic packaging from achieving circular economy goals. Stakeholder interviews and workshops identified contamination in processing facilities, absent regulation, and greenwashing susceptibility as systemic obstacles requiring shared responsibility and simplified materials.

Book Chapter

Industry and Consumer Views on Improving Sustainability and Circularity of Materials Intended for Single Use

AI summary Read the abstract

This study surveyed industry stakeholders and consumers in Germany to understand barriers to adopting sustainable and circular packaging materials, finding that price remains the dominant purchase driver. The research identifies how companies can make sustainable packaging more commercially attractive and how clearer end-of-use guidance can improve recycling rates.

Article Tier 2

An Integrated Analysis of Plastic Packaging Value Chain: Identifying Barriers and Enablers for a Circular Economy

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers analyzed the full plastic packaging value chain to identify barriers and enablers for transitioning to a circular economy, tracing the evolution of circular economy concepts and quantifying the environmental impacts associated with exponential plastic waste growth. The study provides an integrated framework mapping opportunities for intervention across production, use, collection, and recycling stages.

Article

Reflections on Packaging Transitions: Industry Perspectives from SMEs and Large Companies in Sweden

AI summary Read the abstract

Interviews with 26 Swedish companies revealed that packaging transitions face core tensions between functionality and sustainability, cost and innovation, and individual versus systemic action, with plastic still dominating despite gradual shifts toward paper. The study highlights that legislation and large corporations are key drivers shaping industry-wide adoption of sustainable packaging alternatives that could reduce plastic pollution at source.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper