0
Article Sign in to save

Bridging the accountability gap: designing a China-Japan-Korea judicial cooperation framework for transboundary marine plastic pollution

AI summary Read the abstract

Existing governance frameworks for marine plastic pollution in Northeast Asia lack judicial enforcement mechanisms, leaving transboundary pollution cases in an accountability vacuum due to the difficulty of establishing legal causation. This study proposes a trilateral China-Japan-Korea judicial cooperation framework using chemical fingerprinting, oceanographic drift modeling, and market-share liability doctrine to assign pollution responsibility.

Study Type Environmental

Marine plastic pollution in Northeast Asian seas exhibits significant transboundary characteristics, yet existing governance regimes—particularly the Northwest Pacific Action Plan (NOWPAP)—lack judicial enforcement mechanisms to hold polluters accountable. The diffuse nature of pollution renders traditional tort law’s causation requirements inoperative. Objective: This study constructs a trilateral judicial cooperation framework among China, Japan, and Korea to address the accountability vacuum in transboundary marine plastic pollution cases. Employing comparative legal analysis of international environmental tort precedents ( Trail Smelter , Pulp Mills cases) and institutional design methodology, this research adapts the U.S. market-share liability doctrine to transboundary pollution contexts and proposes a three-tier cooperation mechanism. The proposed framework comprises: (1) evidence collection and sharing protocols utilizing chemical fingerprinting and oceanographic drift modeling; (2) jurisdictional coordination rules to prevent forum shopping and parallel litigation; and (3) mutual recognition and enforcement mechanisms for environmental judgments. The framework leverages the existing Tripartite Environment Ministers Meeting (TEMM) platform while transforming it into an enforceable judicial architecture. By reconstructing causation requirements through pollution contribution ratios and establishing systematic judicial cooperation, this framework provides a replicable model for regional ocean governance. It directly contributes to ongoing International Plastics Treaty (INC) negotiations on transboundary liability provisions and demonstrates how soft law regimes can evolve into hard enforcement mechanisms. Yet the framework’s practical realization ultimately depends on participating states’ political will, their readiness to accept reciprocal enforcement obligations, and the gradual evolution of existing regional arrangements. Accordingly, the analysis treats the proposed architecture as a normative blueprint and feasibility exploration rather than an immediately operational regime. Given uneven doctrinal development and limited publicly accessible case law in Japan and Korea, the comparative assessment is necessarily selective, highlighting areas where further empirical and diplomatic work will be required.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

A Study on Transboundary Governance of Marine Plastic Debris—the Case of an Adjacent Waters between China and Taiwan

AI summary Read the abstract

This study constructed a transboundary marine governance mechanism for the Kinmen-Xiamen Waters between China and Taiwan using literature review, field surveys, interviews, and expert opinion surveys. Monsoons, ocean currents, and tides were identified as the primary factors transporting marine plastic debris from the Xiamen Sea to Kinmen beaches, where plastic, bamboo, and wood are the dominant debris types. The study proposes a cross-jurisdictional governance framework to address shared marine plastic pollution affecting coastal ecosystems and rare wildlife including horseshoe crabs and Indo-Pacific dolphins.

Article Tier 2

From weak governance to strong governance: doctrinal reflection and adjustment of transboundary marine ecological environmental governance in China’s Ecological and Environmental Code

AI summary Read the abstract

Ocean pollution like plastic waste and wastewater doesn't stop at national borders, but China's environmental law has weak, vague rules for handling pollution that crosses into other countries' waters. This paper argues for stronger, clearer legal rules on responsibility and cross-border cooperation, which matters because uncontrolled ocean pollution can affect seafood safety and marine ecosystems people depend on worldwide.

Article Tier 2

Institutional fragmentation and legal frameworks of marine plastic governance in China and Pakistan: a CPEC bilateral cooperation proposal

AI summary Read the abstract

This paper compares how China and Pakistan legally tackle ocean plastic pollution, finding China has stronger, more unified rules while Pakistan's efforts are patchy across provinces. Since ocean plastic breaks down into microplastics that end up in our seafood and water, the authors suggest the two countries team up on shared standards and monitoring, since plastic pollution does not stop at borders.

Article Tier 2

China’s approach to tackling marine plastic pollution: an institutional analysis centered on the ecological and environmental code

AI summary Read the abstract

This paper examines China's new Ecological and Environmental Code and how it addresses ocean plastic pollution by linking land and sea rules across production, use and disposal. Comparing it with laws in the European Union, Japan and South Korea, the study finds gaps in areas like producer responsibility rules and suggests areas for future improvement.

Article

Compliance mechanisms of the draft global plastics treaty: theory, current status, and prospects

AI summary Read the abstract

Analysis of five UN INC sessions on the Global Plastics Treaty reveals deep divergences on compliance mechanisms, financing, and technology transfer that have stalled progress since the 2022 UNEA resolution. The article argues the treaty must operationalize common-but-differentiated responsibilities, establish robust non-compliance procedures, and secure sustainable financial support to meaningfully curb transboundary marine plastic pollution.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper