0
Article Sign in to save

Science-policy interface for marine plastic pollution: how can visualisations contribute to decision-support?

AI summary Read the abstract

A discrete choice experiment with Korean respondents using a hybrid latent-attitude model found significant heterogeneity in willingness to pay for forest restoration, with risk sensitivity and cost aversion more strongly driving segmentation than environmental attitudes alone. Understanding public valuation of ecosystem restoration provides methodological insights applicable to designing policy frameworks for coastal and riparian plastic pollution remediation, where long timelines and uncertain outcomes similarly challenge public willingness to pay.

Abstract Plastic pollution is detrimental to nature and human health both at local and global levels. Through this study, we explore the perceptions of the marine plastic problem and solutions by stakeholders in Ålesund, Norway in a focus group setting. We used three visualisation-based interventions aiming to improve the overview of the problem, uncertainty communication and empathy. Firstly, decision-support tools (DSTs) with visually intuitive statistics of the most frequently found litter types were used by the participants in their discussion. Secondly, a visual citizen science exercise enabled them to experience scientific uncertainty first-hand. And thirdly, images of fish gills with plastic fibres were shown as an illustration of the local effects of marine plastic on wildlife. We sorted the proposed solutions per leverage point categories according to intent, design, feedback and parameters, and found an overwhelming majority under parameters, i.e. the shallowest leverage point category. There was little change in the leverage point categories throughout the focus group. We also explored the participants’ interpretation of scientific information and specifically risk and uncertainty. We found the uncertainty communication intervention to be a powerful trigger for a sense of urgency and a better understanding of scientific uncertainty. On the other hand, the results from the empathy intervention were challenging to interpret as several factors played into the dynamic of the conversations. Some participants expressed sadness, others highlighted the inadequacy of current regulations, and others still attempted to diffuse the tension. Based on our findings, we question the use of analytical DSTs alone, and define a research agenda on how visualisations can help high quality action-driven decisions through uncertainty communication and empathy to stimulate the sense of urgency needed. We provide some thoughts on how we, as scientists, can better reach decision-makers to build mutual trust and encourage wise, empathetic policy development grounded in scientific evidence.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Revealing the Invisible: Marine Plastic Waste and its Effects in Science-Inspired Visual Art

AI summary Read the abstract

This paper explores how science-inspired visual art can make invisible marine plastic pollution perceptible to the public by translating scientific data into aesthetic experiences. The authors argue that artistic visualizations close the perceived distance between everyday life and ocean plastic harm, fostering stronger public engagement with pollution issues.

Article Tier 2

Marine litter: Social representations and persuasion in science communication through infographics

AI summary Read the abstract

This study investigated how people's pre-existing social representations of marine litter affect how they process persuasive science communication via digital infographics, finding that audiences' prior beliefs influence their attitude formation when encountering plastic pollution messages.

Article Tier 2

Risk Perception of Plastic Pollution: Importance of Stakeholder Involvement and Citizen Science

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers examine how people perceive the risk of plastic pollution and find that eight key factors — including visibility, familiarity, and severity — shape public and policy responses. Greater involvement of citizens and stakeholders in science could improve risk understanding and lead to more effective regulations.

Article

How frames and narratives in press releases shape newspaper science articles: the case of ocean plastic pollution.

AI summary Read the abstract

This study analyzed how university press releases frame ocean plastic science research and how these frames are adopted, adapted, or omitted by newspaper journalists, using Entman's framing theory on a paired dataset. Results show that journalists frequently reproduce press release framing and quotes, with scientists portrayed as heroes or warners, while social context and non-scientific perspectives remain largely absent from coverage.

Article

How frames and narratives in press releases shape newspaper science articles: the case of ocean plastic pollution

AI summary Read the abstract

This study analyzed how university press releases about ocean plastic research shape newspaper science coverage, using Entman's framing theory and a novel visualization technique to compare content across 'problem definitions, causes, moral judgments, and solutions.' Results showed journalists frequently adopt framing and quotes directly from press releases, with scientists consistently portrayed as heroes or warners, while non-scientific actors and victim perspectives are rarely included, limiting the social embedding of ocean plastic pollution in media coverage.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper