0
Article Sign in to save

Evaluating the Circular Footprint Formula (CFF) in the environmental assessment of mono-material carpets recycling: a case study approach

AI summary Read the abstract

Applying the EU's Circular Footprint Formula to thermomechanically recycled mono-material polyester carpets found that fiber-to-fiber recycling generally produces lower environmental impacts than incineration, though results vary considerably by allocation method and parameter choices. This work is relevant to microplastic research as polyester textiles are a major source of fiber microplastics, and improved recycling reduces plastic pollution entering the environment.

The purpose of this study is to apply and evaluate the Circular Footprint Formula (CFF), as part of the European Commission’s Product Environmental Footprint (PEF) framework, through an assessment of the environmental performance of thermomechanically recycled mono-material polyester carpets. Unlike multi-material carpets that are often incinerated at the end of their life, mono-material designs facilitate fiber-to-fiber recycling - a key priority for the European Union in reducing the large environmental burdens of the textile industry. The environmental assessment is structured around the CFF as recycling allocation method. In addition, a comparison is made with the 100:0 approach as a benchmark, also known as the cut-off or recycled content method, as recommended in the Environmental Product Declaration (EPD). Different potential values for two main parameters within the CFF were considered: factor A, reflecting the market dynamics of supply and demand for recycled materials, and factor B, distributing the burdens and credits associated with energy recovery. Both allocation methods were applied to the carpet case study, which considered three possible scenarios: recycling of the monomaterial carpet (MMC), incineration of the conventional multi-material carpet, and incineration of the MMC. The impact assessment follows the indicators defined by PEF framework. The findings indicate that recycling of MMCs generally results in lower environmental impacts than direct incineration across most impact categories, thereby aligning with the principles of a circular economy. Importantly, incinerating MMCs without prior recycling can lead to more severe environmental burdens than the incineration of conventional carpets, as demonstrated through a comparative product system-level analysis. The results also suggest that factor A has a significantly greater influence on environmental outcomes at individual product level than factor B, with changes in A, for example, leading to impact differences of up to 30% for Climate Change. Additionally, yarn thickness (titer) plays an important role, as a shift from very fine to coarse yarns altered the relative environmental performance of the product systems. Methodological enhancements are recommended to improve the accuracy of environmental impact assessments for textile recycling scenarios when using the CFF within the PEF framework. The high sensitivity to factor A emphasizes the need for a scientifically robust selection process. Moreover, the substantial influence of yarn thickness underscores the importance of developing more detailed Environmental Footprint (EF) datasets to achieve more consistent and reliable sustainability evaluations in the textile sector.

More Papers Like This

Review

Life cycle assessment applications to reuse, recycling and circular practices for textiles: A review

AI summary Read the abstract

This review of 45 life cycle assessment studies on textile waste management found that separate collection followed by reuse yields the greatest environmental benefits, while textile incineration with mixed municipal waste is the second-largest contributor to climate change after plastics.

Article

Fibre-to-Fibre Recycling in Textiles: Strategies, Limitations and Industrial Perspectives

AI summary Read the abstract

This review analyzes fibre-to-fibre textile recycling strategies for cotton, polyester, viscose, polyamide, and wool, identifying feedstock heterogeneity, fibre blending, and quality degradation as the main barriers to scaling circular textile systems. Improving textile recycling is directly relevant to microplastic pollution, as synthetic textile fibres—particularly polyester—are among the largest sources of microplastic fibre release into wastewater and the environment.

Article Tier 2

Comparing the financial costs and carbon neutrality of polyester fibres produced from 100% bio-based PET, 100% recycled PET, or in combination

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers compared the financial costs and carbon footprint of producing polyester fibers from 100% bio-based sources versus enzymatic hydrolysis of recycled PET textiles, designing and simulating both production routes. The study found that the two approaches differ substantially in economic and environmental performance, with implications for sustainable fashion industry decisions.

Article Tier 2

Microfibers in Life Cycle Assessment: Comparing the Physical Effects of Cellulosic and Synthetic Fibers via Characterization Factors Development

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers developed characterization factors for comparing the physical ecotoxicity of cellulosic and synthetic microfibers in Life Cycle Assessment, finding that despite high environmental abundance, cellulosic fibers had been previously excluded from LCA comparisons due to lack of species sensitivity data.

Article

Uncertainty of Life Cycle Assessment Studies for Blended Textiles

AI summary Read the abstract

This study assessed the environmental impact uncertainty of cotton-polyester blended textiles using life cycle assessment, finding that gaps in inventory data produce results varying by up to 772% from baseline scenarios, highlighting the need for standardized reporting before reliable environmental assessments of blended fabrics are possible.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper