0
Article Sign in to save

Critical Positions in the Evaluation of “One Health”-Related Socio-Scientific Issues

AI summary Read the abstract

A teaching study with 9th graders found that exposure to socio-scientific issues — including microplastic pollution — through a One Health framework significantly improved students' ability to develop critical positions, with stronger One Health reasoning correlating with better critical evaluation skills by the end of the sequence. This matters for microplastic research because it shows science education framed around systemic environmental health can build public literacy about emerging pollutants.

Critical thinking is essential for managing socio-scientific issues (SSIs) and can be enacted through informal and rational reasoning for decision-making. Addressing SSIs from a systemic view, such as the One Health (OH) view, can improve their comprehension. This study explores how a group of 9th graders engaged in the practice of critical thinking in a teaching sequence that included different SSIs (antibiotic resistance, microplastic pollution, and avian flu) from an OH vision. The research questions are: (1) What is the ability of students to develop a critical position in the evaluation of claims related to SSI with an OH view? (2) What are the interactions between students’ critical positions and OH views expressed by them in different SSI contexts? Written answers from two activities at different moments of the sequence were analyzed qualitatively. Most students did not develop a critical position in the beginning; however, they did so at the end. No interaction was observed between the ability to develop a critical position and the OH view at the beginning. Students with a critical position at the end showed the highest levels of OH view. These results highlight the need to further investigate the relationships between critical positions and OH views.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Addressing the topic, Microplastics in Human Blood, in school – Connecting school students' and scientists' perspectives

AI summary Read the abstract

This study developed educational approaches to help school students critically engage with the topic of microplastics in human blood, which is often framed as alarming in public discourse despite significant scientific uncertainty about health relevance. The curriculum connected blood microplastic findings to broader science literacy skills including evidence appraisal and risk communication.

Article Tier 2

Addressing the topic, Microplastics in Human Blood, in school – Connecting school students' and scientists' perspectives

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers examined the disconnect between public concern and scientific evidence about microplastics in human blood, developing educational approaches to help school students engage critically with the topic. The study identified strategies for connecting classroom learning about blood microplastics to broader science literacy and evidence-based thinking skills.

Article

Critical Environmental Education and Plastic Pollution in Elementary School - final years

AI summary Read the abstract

Applying critical environmental education based on Reigota's framework in elementary schools successfully broadened students' understanding of plastic pollution impacts and fostered civic engagement with local environmental problems. Early education about plastic waste is foundational for building societal awareness of microplastic pollution and empowering future generations to support reduction and remediation efforts.

Article

Microplásticos No Ensino De Ciências: Revisão Bibliográfica Sobre Estratégias Pedagógicas, Abordagens Ambientais E Lacunas Relacionadas À Saúde Humana

AI summary Read the abstract

A literature review of science education materials found that teaching about microplastics overwhelmingly emphasizes environmental awareness while largely ignoring human health impacts — including evidence that microplastics have been detected in human organs like the liver, lungs, placenta, and breast milk. This gap in curricula limits students' critical understanding of microplastics as a public health issue, not just an ecological one.

Article Tier 2

Plastic Not-So-Fantastic: A One Health Approach to a Growing Crisis

AI summary Read the abstract

This One Health perspective reviews how microplastics affect environmental, animal, and human health, synthesizing evidence that these particles disrupt ecosystems and accumulate in tissues across species, underscoring the need for an integrated response.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper