0
Article Tier 2 Policy & Risk Sign in to save

Microplastic regulation should be more precise to incentivize both innovation and environmental safety

Nature Communications 2020 418 citations

AI summary Read the abstract

This perspective argued that regulatory restrictions on intentional primary microplastics should be more precise and differentiated, acknowledging that hazard uncertainty and the availability of substitutes vary greatly by application, and that blunt bans may sometimes cause greater harm than the microplastics they replace.

The presence of plastic in the environment has sparked discussion amongst scientists, regulators and the general public as to how industrialization and consumerism is shaping our world. Here we discuss restrictions on the intentional use of primary microplastics: small solid polymer particles in applications ranging from agriculture to cosmetics. Microplastic hazards are uncertain, and actions are not similarly prioritized by all actors. In some instances, replacement is technically simple and easily justified, but in others substitutions may come with more uncertainty, performance questions and costs. Scientific impact assessment of primary microplastics compared to their alternatives relies on a number of factors, such as microplastic harm, existence of replacement materials and the quality, cost and hazards of alternative materials. Regulations need a precise focus and must be enforceable by these measurements. Policymakers must carefully evaluate under which contexts incentives to replace certain microplastics can stimulate innovation of new, more competitive and environmentally conscious materials.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Microplastic regulation should be more precise to incentivize both innovation and environmental safety

AI summary Read the abstract

This commentary argues that current microplastic regulations are too broad and imprecise, failing to distinguish between harmful and benign microplastic applications. The authors call for more targeted regulation that incentivizes innovation in safer materials while effectively controlling the most environmentally damaging uses of microplastics.

Article Tier 2

The emergence of microplastics: charting the path from research to regulations

AI summary Read the abstract

This study summarized recent groundbreaking microplastic research and emerging regulations, charting the path from scientific discovery to policy action and providing recommendations to overcome remaining regulatory barriers.

Article Tier 2

Exploring the Essential Use Concept for Primary Microplastics Regulation in the EU

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers explored how the "essential use" concept could be applied to regulate primary microplastics intentionally added to products in the EU. They analyzed different product categories to determine where microplastic use might be considered essential versus where viable alternatives already exist. The study provides a framework for policymakers to systematically phase out unnecessary microplastic uses while allowing them only in applications where no adequate substitutes are available.

Article Tier 2

Microplastics: Emerging Contaminants Requiring Multilevel Management

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers reviewed the growing body of evidence on microplastics as widespread environmental pollutants, documenting their presence everywhere from mountain lakes to deep ocean sediments and inside organisms from tiny invertebrates to whales, while outlining the urgent need for coordinated management strategies spanning industrial regulation, waste collection, and government bans on specific plastic products.

Article Tier 2

Navigating regulatory complexity: Challenges and shifting problem framings in turning microplastics into a European policy object

AI summary Read the abstract

This paper analyzed the challenges regulators face in governing micro- and nanoplastics, examining how shifting problem framings, ambiguous definitions, and material heterogeneity have destabilized regulatory efforts. The study traced how disputes over whether microplastics are a safety or environmental issue have complicated the development of coherent international regulatory frameworks.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper