0
Article Tier 2 Environmental Sources Sign in to save

Approved with minor revision.

2020

AI summary Read the abstract

This is a brief peer review recommendation for publication of a microplastic contamination methods article, with minor revision requests, not containing original research findings.

The authors discuss microplastic contamination and detail several limitations of methods currently in use. They rise several complementary research questions that should be tackled in future. Generally, the article is beautifully written. The idea of the article is original, figures and tables are clear. I recommend this article for publishing after some minor modifications: Line 85 The aim of this review is to collect data about common soil MP concentrations, sizes, shapes and types under the influence of different anthropogenic parameters." I think the article goes further so I suggest improving this sentence. Based on the authors experience: could they add a table summarizing the pros and cons of each method for measuring MP in the soil. Line 365 -370 ". . .which increase with the number of sewage sludge applications (Corradini et al.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Sample Preparation and Analysis Methods of Microplastics

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers worked to establish a standardized method for detecting and measuring microplastics in textile industry wastewater, aiming to create consistent protocols that can be applied across different matrices to better understand how synthetic fibers from manufacturing enter the environment.

Systematic Review Tier 1

Identification and analysis of microplastics: a systematic review of methods and techniques

AI summary Read the abstract

This systematic review of 180 microplastics studies found that µFTIR, µRaman, and pyrolysis-GC/MS are the dominant identification methods, with zinc chloride and hydrogen peroxide the most common chemicals for density separation and organic matter digestion respectively. Methodological variation across studies limits result comparability, and the review recommends standardizing reporting by identification method and carefully matching density separation solutions to target polymer densities.

Article Tier 2

Methods for Studying Microplastic Pollution in Natural Waters: Current State and Recommendations

AI summary Read the abstract

This methodological review addresses the lack of standardization in how scientists sample, process, and report microplastic contamination in natural waters, which makes it nearly impossible to compare results across studies. It details quality assurance and quality control steps — especially important given how easily tiny plastic particles contaminate samples from the lab environment itself — and provides concrete recommendations for sampling protocols and data reporting. Harmonizing these methods is a critical step toward building a reliable global database of microplastic pollution.

Article Tier 2

Assessment of microplastic content in natural waters and sediments: sampling and sample preparation

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers reviewed and evaluated sampling and analytical methods for measuring microplastic content in natural waters and sediments, assessing sources of error and variability in current approaches. The review recommended a standardized protocol to improve cross-study comparability.

Article Tier 2

An insight into different microplastic detection methods

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers critically reviewing microplastic detection methods evaluated analytical techniques including spectroscopy and mass spectrometry alongside emerging sensor-based approaches, identifying the flaws of current methods and proposing novel combinatory strategies to reduce false-positive and false-negative results.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper