We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Partitioning fish communities into guilds for ecological analyses: an overview of current approaches and future directions
Summary
This review examined approaches to partitioning fish communities into functional guilds for ecological analyses, evaluating how guild-based groupings can simplify community analysis and help study functional diversity and community responses to environmental disturbances including pollution.
A major strength of the guild approach is its ability to simplify community analysis by aggregating species with similar roles or functions into groups. These groups can be used to study a number of important ecological concepts, including functional diversity, community response to disturbance, and food-web dynamics. Despite increased use, guild membership can be based on subjective criteria that are arbitrarily chosen, leading to inconsistencies across studies. Additionally, studies using the guild approach generally ignore ontogenetic changes in diet and habitat use and therefore do not fully capture the complexity of aquatic communities. Although these issues have been discussed in the literature, much has changed since the last review was published a decade ago. In our examination, we discuss data requirements and consequences of data availability and reliability on guild formation. We identify bootstrapping and permutation techniques developed to address limitations through cluster validation and the identification of ontogenetic shifts prior to guild delineation. Lastly, we provide a step-by-step guide to guild analysis, accompanied by a decision tree, to facilitate objective and informed guild creation.
Sign in to start a discussion.
More Papers Like This
Functional trait‐based approaches as a common framework for aquatic ecologists
This paper proposes a functional trait-based framework to unify aquatic ecology research across freshwater, marine, benthic, and pelagic systems. By using organism traits rather than taxonomic identity as the common currency, the framework aims to enable knowledge sharing and the discovery of general ecological rules across ecosystems.
Non-Linear Analyses of Fish Behaviours in Response to Aquatic Environmental Pollutants—A Review
This review examined non-linear analytical methods including fractal dimension and entropy for analyzing fish behavioral responses to aquatic pollutants, discussing how these computational approaches can extract meaningful patterns from complex behavioral data streams.
Multispecies assemblages and multiple stressors: Synthesizing the state of experimental research in freshwaters
This synthesis of experimental freshwater research on multispecies assemblages under multiple stressors found that most studies used only two species and two stressors, revealing important knowledge gaps about how real-world complexity of biodiversity loss and combined pollution affects freshwater ecosystem function.
Responses to environmentally relevant microplastics are species-specific with dietary habit as a potential sensitivity indicator
Species-specific responses to environmentally relevant microplastic concentrations were assessed across multiple marine organisms within a functional group study. Results showed that responses differed substantially between species, indicating that single-species tests cannot reliably predict community-level effects of microplastic contamination.
Presença e efeitos da poluição plástica em peixes marinhos e de água doce
This thesis (in Portuguese) investigates plastic contamination in freshwater and marine fish, examining physiological, functional, and ecological effects across multiple levels of biological organization, including food safety implications for human consumption. The author finds that the scientific community has made progress on understanding individual-level effects but that broader ecological impacts and ecosystem-level consequences remain underexplored. The work contributes important evidence that plastic pollution in fish poses intertwined risks for wildlife and the people who eat them.