We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
A Cross Disciplinary Framework for Cost-Benefit Optimization of Marine Litter Cleanup at Regional Scale
Summary
This paper presents a cost-benefit framework for prioritizing where and how to clean up marine litter at regional scale. The framework considers factors like litter type, removal cost, ecological damage, and population exposure. Better economic tools for prioritizing cleanup could help direct limited resources toward areas where marine plastic removal has the greatest benefit.
Litter cleanup and disposal management in the marine environment are increasingly subject to public scrutiny, government regulation and stakeholder initiatives. In practice, ongoing efforts and new investment decisions, for example in new cleanup technologies, are constrained by financial and economic resources. Given budgetary restrictions, it is important to optimize decision-making using a scientific framework that takes into account the various effects of investments by combining multiple scientific perspectives and integrating these in a consistent and coherent way. Identifying optimal levels of marine litter cleanup is a challenge, because of its cross-disciplinary nature, involving physics, environmental engineering, science, and economics. In this paper, we propose a bridge-building, spatial cost-benefit optimization framework that allows prioritizing where to apply limited cleanup efforts within a regional spatial network of marine litter sources, using input from the maturing field of marine litter transport modeling. The framework also includes ecosystem functioning in relation to variable litter concentrations, as well as the potentially non-linear cost-efficiency of cleanup technologies. From these three components (transport modeling, ecosystem functioning, cleanup-effectiveness), along with litter source mapping, we outline the optimal cleanup solution at any given ecological target or economic constraint, as well as determine the cleanup feasibility. We illustrate our framework in a Baltic and Mediterranean Sea case study, using real data for litter transport and cleanup technology. Our study shows that including pollution Green's functions is essential to assess the feasibility of cleanup and determine optimal deployment of cleanup investments, where the presented framework combines physical, economical, technological and biological data consistently to compare and rank alternatives.
Sign in to start a discussion.
More Papers Like This
The Economics of Marine Litter
This paper analyzed the economics of marine litter, estimating the costs imposed on fishing, tourism, and coastal communities and arguing that the economic case for prevention and cleanup is substantial.
Evaluating the environmental impact of cleaning the North Pacific Garbage Patch
Researchers developed a novel plastic pollution impact assessment framework and applied it to evaluate whether cleanup operations targeting the North Pacific Garbage Patch could deliver a net environmental benefit, finding that removing legacy plastic pollution from the subtropical gyre may benefit marine life and carbon cycling when assessed against the environmental costs of the cleanup itself.
Regional management options for floating marine litter in coastal waters from a life cycle assessment perspective
A life cycle assessment evaluated regional management options for floating marine litter in coastal waters, comparing collection, prevention, and disposal strategies to identify the most environmentally favorable approaches for marine litter governance.
Evaluating the net environmental impact of removing plastic pollution from the North Pacific Garbage Patch
Researchers conducted a lifecycle assessment to evaluate the net environmental impact of removing legacy plastic pollution from the North Pacific Garbage Patch, weighing the ecological harm reduction from plastic removal against the environmental costs of cleanup operations including fuel consumption and bycatch. The study found that ocean plastic cleanup can deliver a net environmental benefit when operations are optimised, but that the balance depends critically on vessel efficiency, cleanup technology, and the degradation state of targeted plastics.
Decision-science navigates trade-offs between environmental and socio-economic objectives for marine debris mitigation
Researchers applied decision-science methods to evaluate marine debris management strategies across Southeast Asia, balancing environmental protection with socio-economic impacts. They found that structured decision-making helped identify the best sites and approaches for reducing plastic exposure to marine ecosystems and coastal communities. The study demonstrates how systematic frameworks can navigate the complex trade-offs involved in tackling ocean plastic pollution.