Potential Artifacts and Control Experiments in Toxicity Tests of Nanoplastic and Microplastic Particles
Environmental Science & Technology2022
53 citations
?
Citation count from OpenAlex, updated daily. May differ slightly from the publisher's own count.
Score: 55
?
0–100 AI score estimating relevance to the microplastics field. Papers below 30 are filtered from public browse.
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Antonio R. Montoro Bustos,
Elijah J. Petersen
Elijah J. Petersen
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Elijah J. Petersen
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Ana C. Barrios,
Ana C. Barrios,
Ana C. Barrios,
Elijah J. Petersen
Monique E. Johnson,
Monique E. Johnson,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Antonio R. Montoro Bustos,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Theodore B. Henry,
Theodore B. Henry,
Theodore B. Henry,
Theodore B. Henry,
Theodore B. Henry,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Monique E. Johnson,
Joanna Matheson,
Theodore B. Henry,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Theodore B. Henry,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Antonio R. Montoro Bustos,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Joanna Matheson,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Antonio R. Montoro Bustos,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Joanna Matheson,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Theodore B. Henry,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Matthias Roesslein,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Jian Zhao,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Theodore B. Henry,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Jian Zhao,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Joanna Matheson,
Baoshan Xing,
Baoshan Xing,
Albert A. Koelmans,
Elijah J. Petersen
Summary
This review highlighted potential measurement artifacts and the importance of proper control experiments in toxicity studies of nanoplastics and microplastics. The study cautions that antimicrobials, surfactants, and other additives present in commercial plastic particle dispersions may account for observed toxic effects rather than the particles themselves, emphasizing the need for rigorous experimental design in microplastic toxicology research.
Study Type
In vivo
To fully understand the potential ecological and human health risks from nanoplastics and microplastics (NMPs) in the environment, it is critical to make accurate measurements. Similar to past research on the toxicology of engineered nanomaterials, a broad range of measurement artifacts and biases are possible when testing their potential toxicity. For example, antimicrobials and surfactants may be present in commercially available NMP dispersions, and these compounds may account for toxicity observed instead of being caused by exposure to the NMP particles. Therefore, control measurements are needed to assess potential artifacts, and revisions to the protocol may be needed to eliminate or reduce the artifacts. In this paper, we comprehensively review and suggest a next generation of control experiments to identify measurement artifacts and biases that can occur while performing NMP toxicity experiments. This review covers the broad range of potential NMP toxicological experiments, such as <i>in vitro</i> studies with a single cell type or complex 3-D tissue constructs, <i>in vivo</i> mammalian studies, and ecotoxicity experiments testing pelagic, sediment, and soil organisms. Incorporation of these control experiments can reduce the likelihood of false positive and false negative results and more accurately elucidate the potential ecological and human health risks of NMPs.