0
Review ? AI-assigned paper type based on the abstract. Classification may not be perfect — flag errors using the feedback button. Tier 2 ? Original research — experimental, observational, or case-control study. Direct primary evidence. Environmental Sources Human Health Effects Marine & Wildlife Policy & Risk Remediation Sign in to save

The performance and environmental impact of pro-oxidant additive containing plastics in the open unmanaged environment—a review of the evidence

Royal Society Open Science 2023 25 citations ? Citation count from OpenAlex, updated daily. May differ slightly from the publisher's own count. Score: 55 ? 0–100 AI score estimating relevance to the microplastics field. Papers below 30 are filtered from public browse.
Fabiola Sciscione, Silvia Anselmi, Helen C. Hailes, Mark Miodownik

Summary

Researchers reviewed the evidence on plastics containing pro-oxidant additives, marketed as biodegradable alternatives that break down through oxidation in the natural environment. They found that while these plastics may fragment under hot, dry conditions, there is limited evidence that they fully biodegrade in cooler or wetter climates, and they may simply produce microplastic fragments faster. The study raises concerns that these products could worsen rather than solve microplastic pollution.

Pro-oxidant additive containing (PAC) plastics is a term that describes a growing number of plastics which are designed to degrade in the unmanaged natural environment (open-air, soil, aquatic) through oxidation and other processes. It is a category that includes 'oxo-degradable' plastics, 'oxo-biodegradable' plastics and those containing 'biotransformation' additives. There is evidence that a new standard PAS 9017 : 2020 is relevant to predicting the timescale for abiotic degradation of PAC plastic in hot dry climates under ideal conditions (data reviewed for South of France and Florida). There are no reliable data to date to show that the PAS 9017 : 2020 predicts the timescale for abiotic degradation of PAC plastics in cool or wet climatic regions such as the UK or under less ideal conditions (soil burial, surface soiling etc.). Most PAC plastics studied in the literature showed biodegradability values in the range 5-60% and would not pass the criteria for biodegradability set in the new PAS 9017 : 2020. Possible formation of microplastics and cross-linking have been highlighted both by field studies and laboratory studies. Systematic eco-toxicity studies are needed to assess the possible effect of PAC additives and microplastics on the environment and biological organisms.

Sign in to start a discussion.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Prooxidant-based polyolefins exhibiting no evidence of biodegradation under marine environments

Researchers tested whether polyethylene and polypropylene films containing oxo-biodegradable additives actually break down in marine environments. They found no evidence of biodegradation for any of the prooxidant-containing plastics, even after extended exposure to marine conditions. The study suggests that oxo-biodegradable plastics may simply fragment into microplastics rather than truly degrading in ocean settings.

Article Tier 2

Comparison of the behaviour of pro-oxidant additive containing plastic degradation in the unmanaged natural environment and in the laboratory.

Researchers compared the degradation behavior of pro-oxidant additive containing (PAC) plastics in unmanaged natural environments versus laboratory conditions defined by the PAS 9017:2020 standard, finding discrepancies between laboratory-predicted and real-world biodegradation outcomes.

Article Tier 2

Oxo-Additives for Polyolefin Degradation: Kinetics and Mechanism

This review examines how oxo-additives — metal salt compounds added to polyethylene and polypropylene to speed up oxidation — affect how fast these plastics break down in the environment. The research is directly relevant to microplastics because oxo-degradable plastics were marketed as an environmental solution but evidence suggests they may instead fragment into persistent microplastics rather than truly biodegrading, and this review helps clarify the conditions under which each outcome occurs.

Article Tier 2

Biodegradable microplastics (BMPs): a new cause for concern?

This review examined whether biodegradable microplastics present new environmental hazards, finding that many biodegradable polymers degrade slowly under real environmental conditions and can release toxic additives, and that the assumption of biodegradability does not eliminate microplastic pollution risks unless composting conditions are actively managed.

Article Tier 2

Study on the degradability of plastics with prodegradant additives during anaerobic and aerobic biological waste treatment processes

Researchers evaluated whether PP and PET plastic packaging specimens containing commercially available prodegradant additives actually degrade under simulated composting and anaerobic digestion conditions. None of the materials fragmented into microplastic particles larger than 1 mm under the tested conditions, though FTIR detected surface oxidation in PP samples and PET specimens showed roughly 6.5% mass loss during anaerobic digestion, calling into question the degradability claims of such additives.

Share this paper