0
Systematic Review Tier 1 Food & Water Marine & Wildlife Policy & Risk Remediation Sign in to save

Biodegradability of bioplastics in different aquatic environments: A systematic review

Journal of Environmental Sciences 2023 62 citations

AI summary Read the abstract

This systematic review examines whether bioplastics actually break down in water as promised. The findings reveal wide variability in how well different bioplastics biodegrade in freshwater and saltwater, and current testing standards lack clear targets, meaning some materials marketed as biodegradable may still persist in the environment and contribute to microplastic pollution.

Study Type Review

Bioplastics were first introduced as environmentally friendly materials, with properties similar to those of conventional plastics. A bioplastic is defined as biodegradable if it can be decomposed into carbon dioxide under aerobic degradation, or methane and CO2 under anaerobic conditions, inorganic compounds, and new cellular biomass, by the action of naturally occurring microorganisms. This definition however does not provide any information on the environmental conditions, timescale and extent at which decomposition processes should occur. With regard to the aquatic environment, recognized standards have been established to assess the ability of plastics to undergo biodegradation; however, these standards fail to provide clear targets to be met to allow labelling of a bioplastic as biodegradable. Moreover, these standards grant the user an extensive leeway in the choice of process parameters. For these reasons, the comparison of results deriving from different studies is challenging. The authors analysed and discussed the degree of biodegradability of a series of biodegradable bioplastics in aquatic environments (both fresh and salt water) using the results obtained in the laboratory and from on-site testing in the context of different research studies. Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD), CO2 evolution, surface erosion and weight loss were the main parameters used by researchers to describe the percentage of biodegradation. The results showed a large variability both in weight loss and BOD, even when evaluating the same type of bioplastics. This confirms the need for a reference range of values to be established with regard to parameters applied in defining the biodegradability of bioplastics.

More Papers Like This

Review Tier 2

Biodegradability standards for carrier bags and plastic films in aquatic environments: a critical review

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers critically reviewed existing biodegradability standards for carrier bags and plastic films in aquatic environments and found that current testing protocols do not adequately reflect real-world marine or freshwater conditions. The study suggests that labeling plastics as "biodegradable" may be misleading, since degradation rates vary dramatically depending on temperature, oxygen levels, and microbial communities present in natural water bodies.

Article Tier 2

Biodegradable plastics in aquatic ecosystems: latest findings, research gaps, and recommendations

AI summary Read the abstract

This review challenges the assumption that biodegradable plastics are harmless to aquatic ecosystems, finding that many materials labeled as biodegradable do not fully break down in natural water environments. Researchers found that these plastics can persist in aquatic settings and pose similar risks to wildlife as conventional plastics, including ingestion and chemical leaching. The study recommends more rigorous testing of biodegradability claims under real-world aquatic conditions.

Article Tier 2

Biodegradable Plastics: Biodegradation Percentage and Potential Microplastic Contamination in Seawater

AI summary Read the abstract

This study tested the biodegradation of several commercially available biodegradable plastics in seawater, finding that most broke down incompletely and could still generate microplastic fragments. The findings challenge marketing claims about biodegradable plastics and highlight the risk that these materials pose as microplastic sources in marine environments.

Article Tier 2

Bioplastics in the Sea: Rapid In-Vitro Evaluation of Degradability and Persistence at Natural Temperatures

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers evaluated the marine degradability of multiple bioplastic materials at natural seawater temperatures, finding that most bioplastics persist in ocean environments rather than degrading quickly, challenging assumptions that bioplastics represent a straightforward solution to marine plastic pollution.

Article Tier 2

Fate of So‐Called Biodegradable Polymers in Seawater and Freshwater

AI summary Read the abstract

This review examined whether so-called biodegradable plastics actually break down in seawater and freshwater environments, finding that most degrade far too slowly to offer any practical environmental benefit. The study warns that biodegradable labeling can create a false sense of security and may not reduce plastic accumulation in aquatic ecosystems.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper