0
Article Tier 2 Sign in to save

Reply to the Comment by T. Burghardt ‘Microplastic Emissions and Polymer Contents Are Not the Same: Regarding a Confusion in Tatsii et al. “Do Microplastics Contribute to the Total Number Concentration of Ice Nucleating Particles?”’

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers replied to a methodological critique of their study on road traffic-related microplastic contributions to atmospheric ice nucleating particles, clarifying their estimation approach for microplastic number concentrations and defending the validity of the input data and transport model used in the original analysis.

Abstract This reply addresses the comment by T. Burghardt, ‘Microplastic emissions and polymer contents are not the same: regarding a confusion in Tatsii et al. “Do Microplastics Contribute to the Total Number Concentration of Ice Nucleating Particles?’”, on the paper by Tatsii et al. (2025), https://doi.org/10.1029/2024jd042827 . The original study quantified road traffic‐related microplastic number concentrations and estimated their contribution to total ice nucleating particle concentrations using an atmospheric transport model. In this reply, we clarify raised concerns related to the estimation of microplastic emissions from road markings and polymer‐modified bitumen. We further elaborate on the methodology and objectives of our study to resolve the identified misunderstanding. The main conclusion is that applying the emission constraints for road markings and polymer‐modified bitumen proposed by T. Burghardt, values that are one order of magnitude lower than those used in the original study, has a negligible impact on the reported results, as these sources represent a relatively small fraction of the total emissions.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Microplastic Emissions and Polymer Contents Are Not the Same: Regarding a Confusion in Tatsii et al. “Do Microplastics Contribute to the Total Number Concentration of Ice Nucleating Particles?”

AI summary Read the abstract

This commentary identified a critical methodological error in a study on microplastic contributions to atmospheric ice nucleating particles, arguing that the authors incorrectly conflated polymer content in road markings and polymer-modified bitumen with actual microplastic emission rates, which do not directly correspond.

Article Tier 2

Do Microplastics Contribute to the Total Number Concentration of Ice Nucleating Particles?

AI summary Read the abstract

This study measured microplastic concentrations in air near roads and estimated whether road traffic-derived microplastics — from tire wear, brake dust, and road markings — contribute meaningfully to the total number of ice-nucleating particles in the atmosphere. The results showed that traffic-related microplastics do add to ice-nucleating particle counts, though their overall contribution relative to other aerosol sources requires further investigation. The findings are relevant because ice-nucleating particles influence cloud formation and precipitation, meaning airborne microplastics could have subtle effects on regional weather patterns.

Article Tier 2

Do Microplastics Contribute to the Total Number Concentration of Ice Nucleating Particles?

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers modeled road-traffic-related microplastic emissions and estimated their potential contribution to ice-forming particles in clouds. In tropical regions and remote areas like East Antarctica, where other ice-nucleating particles are scarce, microplastics could account for up to 40% of the total ice-nucleating particle concentration. The study suggests that airborne microplastics may be influencing cloud formation and precipitation patterns in ways not previously considered.

Letter Tier 3

Clarifying the importance of microplastic particles as vectors for long-range transport of chemical contaminants: a response to letter to the editor

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers responded to published critiques about their work on microplastics as long-distance carriers of chemical contaminants — such as flame retardants and plasticizers — clarifying that not all microplastic particles behave the same way environmentally. They argue that understanding which types of plastic particles are most likely to transport harmful chemicals over long distances is essential for accurately assessing the true risk of plastic pollution.

Review Tier 2

Reply to road markings and microplastics- a critical literature review

AI summary Read the abstract

Researchers responded to a review that dismissed road markings as a microplastic source, arguing the absence of detections in environmental samples reflects the extreme analytical difficulty of identifying road marking materials — not their actual absence — and calling for more consistent reporting standards across microplastic studies.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper