0
Article Sign in to save

‘Plastic Pollution’ and Plastics as Pollution in Mumbai, India

Journal of Science Technology and Innovation Policy 2020 29 citations

AI summary Read the abstract

This study examined four distinct framings of plastic pollution in Indian public discourse: as spatial displacement, as waste, as environmental pollution, and as symbolic pollution. Using India as a case study, the author argues for greater attention to the aesthetic dimension in understanding how plastic pollution is perceived and acted upon.

In the last decade, plastic pollution has emerged as a major global issue in public discourse. Nonetheless, there is little consensus on which aspects of plastics constitute the problem. In India, litter, unmanaged disposal, lack of biodegradation, wasteful resource use, threats to bodily integrity and the natural order, and national dishonour are all variously associated with ‘plastic pollution’. What exactly, then, does the term reference when used in various streams of public discourse, and what semantic transformations does this imply? Using India as a case study, I examine discourses about plastic pollution and tease out four prominent framings, or senses, of such pollution – as spatial displacement, as waste, as environmental pollution, and as symbolic pollution – and explore their mobilisation by stakeholders. I also make the case for greater attention to the aesthetic dimension as a heuristic framework in knowing and acting upon pollution.

More Papers Like This

Article Tier 2

Review: Global perceptions of plastic pollution: The contours and limits of debate — R0/PR3

AI summary Read the abstract

A review of 39 studies on public perceptions of plastic pollution found that research has clustered around marine ecosystems, single-use plastics, and recycling barriers, while underexploring systemic production reduction and connections to climate change or broader biodiversity loss. The paper emphasizes that terminology choices — 'marine debris' vs. 'microplastics' vs. 'plastic pollution' — frame public understanding differently and should inform policy communications.

Article

Ecocommunicability, citizenship, and discourses on plastic control in India

AI summary Read the abstract

This study evaluated the potential for microplastics to act as carriers for pyrethroid insecticides in agricultural runoff, finding that polystyrene and polyethylene particles sorbed pyrethroids effectively and that sediment-dwelling invertebrates accumulated higher pyrethroid burdens when exposed via plastic carriers compared to equivalent dissolved concentrations. The results suggest microplastics may amplify pesticide bioavailability through vector effects in agricultural drainage.

Article Tier 2

Framing pollution

AI summary Read the abstract

This social science analysis explores how "pollution" — and microplastics specifically — is defined not just by science but by political, economic, and cultural forces. The paper examines different ways of framing microplastic pollution: as a waste management failure, a consumer behavior problem, or an inevitable product of industrial capitalism, each with different implications for who bears responsibility. It argues that understanding the social and political dimensions of microplastic pollution is essential for developing just and effective responses.

Article Tier 2

Global perceptions of plastic pollution: The contours and limits of debate

AI summary Read the abstract

This review analyzed 39 peer-reviewed studies on public perceptions of plastic pollution, finding that research discourse is narrowly focused on marine impacts and single-use plastics while largely ignoring broader plastic pollution contexts relevant to international treaty negotiations.

Article Tier 2

Recommendation: Global perceptions of plastic pollution: The contours and limits of debate — R0/PR4

AI summary Read the abstract

This is a peer review recommendation for a study analyzing 39 published papers on public perceptions of plastic pollution, finding that research has focused mainly on marine ecosystems, single-use plastics, and microplastic risks while underexploring broader production reduction and climate-plastics links. The paper notes that framing choices in terminology shape public understanding and policy responses to the plastic pollution crisis.

Research digests by email

When a large batch of papers lands in the Atlas, we read through it and send a short write-up of what stood out.

Email me about

Share this paper